June 22, 2017

In Defense of Carson Palmer: Message Board Edition

Palmer is probably better than you think.

Most Bengals fans have moved on from Carson Palmer, figuring that his presence alone could poison what figures to be a re-energized locker room. Mike Brown hasn’t. And I haven’t either. I figure if there’s a way to get Carson back on board for one year, it would give Andy Dalton time to adjust, and still give the Bengals their best chance to win in 2011. I also believe Palmer could win over the locker room once again by showing that he’s fully committed to the team, working as hard or harder than everyone else. And I know I’m in the minority here.

Crazy as it may sound, I still believe Palmer is in the upper-echelon of NFL quarterbacks and last year’s struggles were more of a result of miscommunication with new (or undisciplined wideouts), than a general indictment of Palmer overall. Palmer is probably better than you realize.

And there’s someone else out there who feels the same way. Baltus Dinglehammer, a creatively-named denizen of the Bengals message boards, offers up an interesting argument in support of Palmer. It turns out that Carson has had a passer rating of 100 or more in 11 of his 51 losses, which seems to suggest he’s been a consistent victim of bad defense and poor special teams.

It might be an unpopular view, I suppose, but it’s also true. Now, let me get out of the way before the slings and arrows really start to fall.

Click the image to read the full message board post.





  1. Omnipotent_1 says:

    Carson doesn’t have the gonads to comeback and face the guys in the locker room. His mind went back to Cali in week 12 of last year and he is not coming back. If Mike Brown can’t get 2 first round picks for him, then he is worth more to the Bengals retired!

  2. BS.