April 16, 2014

Is Shipley A Lock?

To this point, we have simply assumed that Jordan Shipley will be the starting slot receiver when the season begins. As the second most experienced receiver on the roster, it is a natural assumption. But I am beginning to wonder…

Let me make this caveat now: I am not making the case that Shipley should not be the starter in the slot. Clearly his experience and productivity at the spot (600 yds receiving in his rookie year) gives him the advantage. But he is going up against another talented slot guy in Sanu. And perhaps just assuming the battle is over before it begins is premature.

I won’t label Shipley as injury-prone, but his bad luck has to be noted. He missed 1 game in 2010 after suffering a concussion in Cleveland. And unfortunately his knee was blown out in the second game of the season last year. Hopefully that is the last injury he suffers in his career, and I don’t want to make more out of the injuries than is justified, but they have to be considered.

We also should not underestimate Sanu’s abilities. He is noted for finding the weak spots in the zone, physical blocking, soft hands and a nice catch radius. Check this snippet from a scouting report on him:

If paired with a quality No. 1 WR who commands double teams, Sanu is near impossible to cover in single man coverage. He’s just too physical and uses his body really well to shield defenders. Let him work the short and intermediate game in single man and he’ll be a handful.

I just shivered.

Again, I’m not giving the starting spot to Sanu. But I’m not so sure I’m giving it to Shipley by default either. This will be one more interesting camp battle to watch.

Comments

  1. Sean says:

    I say put Shipley on the PUP list and trade him before the deadline. Let the new guy (Sanu) have the slot, because of his versatility.

    • alekccincy says:

      We will not see a return on investment (3rd round pick) by trading Shipley at this point. That’s crazy talk. Sanu could very well end up on the outside as the #2 with Shipley in the slot (in pro formations). People need not forget that Jermaine Gresham is also a vertical threat, so having a prototypical vertical threat #2 receiver isn’t as critical. That’s not to say Sanu couldn’t prove to be a deep threat, or that he may very well win the slot receiver position. Either way, definitely keep Jordan Shipley with his upside when health, or as excellent depth.

      • Sean says:

        Before last year I would have agreed with you about the ROI of a trade, but don’t forget that MB shocked the world with the Palmer trade. If Shipley is healthy in the middle of the season and another team is in need of a receiver, oh wait, nevermind, Hue Jackson is back coaching for the Bengals….you are completely right.

  2. Eric says:

    I do have reservations about Shipley due to his injury history. The knee is bad, but something that can be overcome. the concussions, however, are another matter. I hope he overcomes this, and can have a highly productive career, but I have my doubts. I’d like Hawkins to get more of an opportunity in the slot as well. Sanu, I believe, will do more work on the outside.

    At any rate, it’ll be an interesting battle